Guide to the David Sindt Papers
Open for research.
To browse this collection's digitized materials visit Pearl.
Materials marked "Digital" in the Collection Inventory may not have been digitized in their entirety.
David Bailey Sindt was born in 1940 and grew up attending Presbyterian churches in Minneapolis, Minnesota. He received his Masters of Divinity in 1966 from McCormick Theological Seminary in Chicago and was ordained in 1965 by the Presbytery of St. Paul in the United Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A. (UPCUSA). In 1971, he attained a Masters of Social Work from the University of Michigan and began working for the Chicago Department of Children and Family Services. Also during that year, David began to identify as an openly gay man. He became active in the Chicago Gay Alliance and simultaneously started worshipping at Lincoln Park Presbyterian Church. In 1972, the Session called David to serve as an assistant pastor and establish an outreach program to the local gay community, but this call was rejected by the Presbytery of Chicago in the UPCUSA the following year. This was believed to be the first call ever issued to an openly gay man by a Presbyterian congregation.
Sindt began sending letters to select Presbyterians early in 1974, hoping to seek out people who would be interested in advocating for gay concerns within the Church. These letters initiated the formation of the Presbyterian Gay Caucus (PGC), which met for the first time at the 1974 UPCUSA General Assembly. At that assembly, Sindt held up a sign that said, "Is Anyone Else Out There Gay?" From this action and David's previous grassroots organizing efforts in the months prior to the 1974 General Assembly, a group came into existence at that time known as the Presbyterian Gay Caucus (PGC). The original, proposed name was Gay United Presbyterians (GUP), but since the organizing efforts had always planned to welcome people of all sexual orientations, including heterosexual allies, PGC was chosen instead. Subsequent name changes during the first seven years were as follows: Presbyterians for Gay Concerns (also PGC, 1977), and Presbyterians for Lesbian/Gay Concerns (PLGC, 1980). PLGC remained the name until 1999 when the organization merged with the More Light Churches Network (MCLN) to form More Light Presbyterians which continues its advocacy work today.
After the formation of the PGC, David spent the next five years as the organization’s national coordinator, helping it to establish a network of LGBTQIA+ individuals and allies throughout the church who could support one another as they worked for full membership and ordination rights. He also continued to work for LGBTQIA+ rights in various gay community organizations in Chicago and was an active member of Lincoln Park Presbyterian Church (LPPC). In David's career as a social worker, he helped organize the National Council on Social Welfare Task Force on Homosexuality and the Gay Community, and also organized the Chicago Gay Social Work Task Force, both in 1972. His activism also inspired the LPPC to create a position paper on LGBT ordination rights in 1980, and in 1981 the Session voted to become a More Light congregation. David was diagnosed with AIDS in 1985 and died on December 3, 1986.
During his life, David also became an internationally recognized authority on dwarf irises, and was recognized as an expert hybridizer. Approximately 51 new iris varieties were introduced from his breeding lines, of which 40 were introduced by David during his lifetime. A number of his introductions won prizes in various competitions, and several received the highest awards from the American Iris Society, as well as awards in international competitions. His 1,000 square foot iris garden in the backyard of his home in Chicago contained the largest collection of pumila irises in the world. He became a judge for the Dwarf Iris Society in 1961 and for the American Iris Society in 1969. He later achieved Master Judge status for the American Iris Society. He served as an officer or board member in several iris societies, including being President of the Northern Illinois Iris Society in 1980-81, President of the Dwarf Iris Society in 1981, and Regional (#9) Vice President of the American Iris Society. After David's death, David's parents, Charlotte and Gustave Sindt, arranged to have David's iris stock moved to the Adamgrove nursery in Missouri where, over the next decade, owners Eric and Robert Tankesley-Clarke introduced an additional five varieties from David's breeding program, and introduced an additional six varieties prepared from hybrids created by David of which the Tankesley-Clarkes then selected the final cut of seedlings, named them and introduced them, listing them as Sindt-Tankesley-Clarke varieties.
The David Sindt Papers document the creation and development of the More Light Movement in the Presbyterian Church. This is a movement for full membership and full participation in the Church for persons who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer or questioning (LGBTQ+) including the rights of ordination as deacon, elder and minister, as well as the right to same gender marriage.
This collection was curated and processed by Barry Smith, the historian at Lincoln Park Presbyterian Church (Chicago, Ill.). A large portion of the materials in the David Sindt Papers were the personal papers and ephemera of David Sindt, documenting his involvement with the More Light Movement. This includes correspondence, newsletters, and ephemera. Additionally, the papers contain more personal documents from his childhood, 4-H activities, college, year abroad, and graduate school. The papers also include material related to his decline in health and his death on December 3, 1986. There are documents that reveal other areas of his life that have received little attention in church circles, both during his life and after, including his career as a social worker and his life-long work with irises.
The collection also includes material collected by Barry Smith and John Hobbs and added posthumously to Sindt’s personal papers. In 2016, Barry Smith started to review the David Sindt Papers that were housed at the Lincoln Park Presbyterian Church (LPPC) archives for scanning, indexing and subsequent donation to the Presbyterian Historical Society. He realized that many of the actions of David Sindt and the early More Light Movement would be clarified and enhanced by merging in some of the records from PLGC/Chicago, That All May Freely Serve (TAMFS)/Chicago, and copies of relevant materials from the LPPC archives as well as an almost complete set of PLGC and MLP newsletters. The PLGC/Chicago records from the 1980s and 1990s were in Barry's possession. The TAMFS/Chicago records from 1997 to 2008 were in the possession of Barry's husband, John Hobbs (a former co-moderator of the TAMFS/Chicago board and a TAMFS/National board member) and Linda Wygant (a former TAMFS/Chicago board member and secretary), and the other additional materials came from the LPPC archives. Barry merged all of these additional documents into the materials that originated from David Sindt and estimates that they constitute about 10% of the total material in the collection. Some of the materials Barry added are from after David's death in 1986, reflecting the work that went forward propelled in part by David's original vision and legacy, and eventually reaching goals that David did not live to see fulfilled.
For a more extensive overview of the collection and the work done to process or add to the material, please consult the Index to the David Sindt Papers created by Barry Smith. The index is also available in Box 1, Folder 1 of the collection.
To browse this collection's digitized materials visit Pearl.
Materials marked "Digital" in the Collection Inventory may not have been digitized in their entirety.
The Presbyterian Historical Society holds additional resources related to this collection:
Researchers should also consult RG 543 (Ralph Carter Papers) for additional material related to the More Light Movement and LGBTQIA+ inclusion in the Presbyterian Church.
Researchers should also consult RG 548 (More Light Presbyterians Records) for additional material related to More Light Presbyterians.
Received from Barry Smith in 2019. Three years earlier, the Session of Lincoln Park Presbyterian Church voted to move the David Sindt Papers from the church archives to the Presbyterian Historical Society with the understanding that Barry Smith, the church historian, would first scan some of the materials in order to retain digital copies for the LPPC archives and then index the collection.
Collection processed in 2019 by Barry Smith, Lincoln Park Presbyterian Church Historian. Smith created an extensive index to the David Sindt Papers, available here and in Box 1, Folder 1. The index includes Smith's annotations on Sindt's papers, his work with processing the collection, and the history of the movement for LGBTQIA+ inclusion in the Presbyterian Church. Parts of the index were edited and uploaded in 2019 to create this online guide by Elizabeth Wittrig, Processing Archivist. The index was edited and uploaded again in 2023. Collection is part of the Pam Byers Memorial Collection.
David Sindt Papers, RG 521, Presbyterian Historical Society, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Box | Folder | Description | Alternative Formats |
---|---|---|---|
1 | 1 | Index to collection; list of deceased More Light Saints, 2023 | Digital |
1 | 2 | Sindt resumes, autobiography, biographies, 1969-2015 | |
1 | 3 | Early years through college, 1952-1962 | |
1 | 4 | McCormick Theological Seminary and Union Theological Seminary papers, 1962-1966 | |
1 | 5 | Ordination papers, 1965-1966 | |
1 | 6 | Congregations Sindt served as assistant pastor, correspondence and reports, 1965-1969 | |
1 | 7 | University of Michigan Graduate School papers and articles, 1970-1971 | |
1 | 8 | Lincoln Park Presbyterian Church LGBTQ actions and call to David Sindt, 1970-1973 | |
1 | 9 | Pre-Presbyterian Gay Caucus, 1970-1973 | |
1 | 9 | Letter from Bill Johnson addressed to David Sindt, December 7, 1973 | Digital |
1 | 10-11 | Call to LGBTQ ministry and attempt to transfer to Chicago Presbytery, 1971-1975 | |
1 | 12-13 | Presbyterian Gay Caucus, 1974-1978 | |
1 | 13 | David Sindt testimony to the Assembly Committee considering the final report of the UPCUSA Task Force to Study Homosexuality, 1978 | Digital |
1 | 14-15 | Presbyterian Gay Caucus, 1974-1978 | |
1 | 17 | UPCUSA 190th General Assembly, 1978 | |
1 | 18 | Presbyterian Gay Caucus, 1979 | |
1 | 19 | Presbyterian Gay Caucus, finances, 1974-1979 | |
1 | 20 | Nomination of David Sindt to LPPC Session, 1979-1982 | |
1 | 21-23 | Presbyterian Gay Caucus/Presbyterians for Lesbian and Gay Concerns, 1980-1982 | |
1 | 24 | LPPC Judicial Actions involving Barry Smith | |
1 | 25-26 | Presbyterians for Lesbian and Gay Concerns, 1983-1984 | |
1 | 27 | Presbyterian Consultation on Homophobia Education and aftermath, 1984-1985 | |
1 | 28 | PC(USA) PJC decision against Westminster Presbyterian Church (Buffalo, NY), 1983-1985 | |
2 | 29-30 | Presbyterians for Lesbian and Gay Concerns, 1985-1986 | |
2 | 31 | PLGC/Chicago - AIDS brochure, 1986-1987 | |
2 | 32 | David Sindt illness, death, and responses, 1983-2018 | |
2 | 33 | Presbyterians for Lesbian and Gay Concerns, 1987 | |
2 | 34 | Settlement of David Sindt's estate, 1986-1988 | |
2 | 35-37 | Presbyterians for Lesbian and Gay Concerns, 1988-1991 | |
2 | 38 | More Light Churches Conference, 1992 | |
2 | 39-40 | Presbyterians for Lesbian and Gay Concerns/More Light Churches, 1992-1999 | |
2 | 41 | More Light Churches Conferences, 1991, 1995-1998 | |
2 | 42 | PGC/PLGC corporate annual reports, 1978-2000 | |
2 | 43 | That All May Freely Serve Chicago, 1997-2017 | Digital |
2 | 44 | That All May Freely Serve Chicago, 1997-2017 | |
2 | 45 | That All May Freely Serve Chicago, 1997-2017 | |
2 | 46 | That All May Freely Serve Chicago, 1997-2017 | Digital |
2 | 47 | That All May Freely Serve Chicago, 1997-2017 | |
2 | 48 | TAMFS - Rock Stars and Prophets Conference, 2015 | |
2 | 49 | More Light Movement resources and reflections, 2000-2018 | |
2 | 50 | Brochures from LGBTQ advocacy groups in the PC(USA), 1975-2008, undated | |
2 | 51 | Articles and papers on LGBTQ issues and religion, 1961-1976 | |
2 | 52 | David Sindt - general theological notes, circa 1970s | |
2 | 53-56 | David Sindt - sermons, 1963-1981 | |
4 | 8 | Audio tape reel: David Sindt - sermon "Gaily Forward," Lincoln Park Presbyterian Church, 1972 | Digital |
3 | 57 | David Sindt - presentation on Psalms, 1980 | |
3 | 58 | David Sindt - record of marriages and unions, 1968-1976 | |
3 | 59 | Lisa Bove Senior College paper on the history of the More Light Movement, 1983 [includes interview with Sindt] | |
3 | 60 | LPPC, More Light documents, 1978-2019 | |
3 | 61 | Barry Smith - highlights of the More Light Movement presentation, 2015 | |
3 | 62 | David Sindt - Christmas letters, 1972-1985 | |
3 | 63 | David Sindt - social work papers and activities, 1970s | |
3 | 64 | David Sindt - iris work, 1952-1986 | |
3 | 65 | David Sindt's parents, Charlotte and Gustave Sindt articles and obituaries, 1978-1995 | Digital |
3 | 66 | Photographs of David Sindt; PLGC leaders and conferences; photographs from LGBTQ advocacy groups in the PC(USA), 1956-1988 | Digital |
3 | 67 | David Sindt - personal correspondence, passports, and certificates, 1960-1979 | |
3 | 68 | Presbyterian Gay Caucus newsletters, 1974-1977 | |
3 | 69 | Presbyterian Gay Caucus/Presbyterians for Lesbian and Gay Concerns newsletters, 1977-1980 | |
3 | 69 | More Light newsletter, number 39, January-February 1980 | Digital |
3 | 70 | PGC/PLGC Synod of Lincoln Trails newsletters, 1978-1980 | |
3 | 71 | PGC/PLGC Synod of the Northeast newsletters, 1978-1980 | |
3 | 72-83 | More Light Update, 1980-2003 | |
3 | 84 | More Light Churches Network newsletters, 1993-1998 | |
4 | 1 | Barry Smith timeline collage of David Sindt's life, 2015 | |
4 | 2-5 | Audiocassette: David Sindt memorial service, 1986 December 13 [3 copies] | |
4 | 6 | Presbyterian Gay Caucus corporate seal, 1974 | |
4 | 7 | Buttons, badges, and pendants for LBGTQIA+ inclusion created by PGC, PLGC, MLP, TAMFS, various More Light Churches Conferences, and individual churches |